The
Board of
Cadbury Nigeria recently discovered overstatement of the
Company ’s financials and consequently requested that the financials be screened by
PricewaterhouseCoopers (Chartered
Accountants ). The outcome is an overstatement of bottom-lines by about N1.5 billion resulting from different
Financial shenanigans employed by the
Company to achieve this.
Prior to the outcome of the investigation, the
Stock which was previously enjoying an average
Daily volume trade of over about 500,000 units was placed on
Technical suspension.
Trading volume declined to a
Low ebb average of 30,000 units while still expecting the outcome of the investigation panel.
From the
Information made available by the
Company , the current year loss is forecasted to be about N5.0 billion and as at September 30 2006, the
Company ’s Net
Asset Value (NAV) has come down to at least about N1.0 billion.
Given this scenario, we STRONGLY RECOMMEND A SELL based on the following analysis:
v The
Company currently has 1,100,842,666 shares outstanding
Out of which 46.3% is held by the parent
Company -
Cadbury Schweppes Overseas .
v In correcting the financials, the
Company ’s Net
Asset Per
share (NAPS) has dropped from N10.86 as at December 2005 to about N0.99 as at September 30, 2006 resulting in about 91% drop.
v Earnings Per
share (EPS) has entered the negative zone from a positive figure of N2.70 as at year ended December 2005.
v Given the
Nigerian investing
Public with pricing mentality based on
Benefits (bonus and dividend) , dividend payment for the next two years would be denied as well as bonus issue for not less than five(5) years after utilizing the available
Capital reserves to absorb losses. In the same vein, the resulting
Capital reserve from planned revaluation exercise is also not available for capitalization issue.
v Though the
Company has a very good margin at an average of 20% CAGR, huge expenses would have to be committed to re-branding thereby eating deep to the upshot.
v Trade receivables as a percentage of turnovers has increased from 23% in 2004 to 31% in 2005. This portends another signal for bad debt provision.
v The parent
Company may salvage momentum drop in
Value given the number of floats outstanding (53.73%), we recommend a SELL before the support level
v The
Company ’s
Price is expected to drop significantly on the floor of the
Exchange with
Daily volume surge at a declining
Price trend. With a Net
Asset of about N1.0billion the
Stock is expected to be on a serious offer on the floor and will most likely in trade below N15.
v
Price will drop significantly in the coming weeks. However, the
Price level will initially stabilize at a range of N10-N15.
Price thereafter will depend on the actions of
New Management team and recovery performance of the
Company in 2007 fiscal year.
v Bye and large, we
Are of the opinion that
Cadbury ’s
Price may not get to the current level in the next 5 years.
Attachment : BRIEF-CADBURY_NIGERIA_PLC DECEMBER2006.pdf
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MERISTEM
Securities Ltd .
124 Norman
Williams Street,
South
West, Ikoyi,
Lagos .
P.O Box 51585
Falomo, Ikoyi,
Lagos .
Phone:234-1-2717350-5; Fax: 234-1-2717356, 2690118.
Website:www.meristemng.com E-mail:info@meristemng.com